Drop by and try their quick lunch.
$15 200 gm Rump Steak with chips and salad... my expectations towards the meat quality had already been managed to a "reasonable" level.
The best part is they asked me how well I wish my steak be done.
I said medium for both as photo.
We have finished both steaks and neither of us could find ANY pink at all.
That's how they do "medium" steak.
My question is... why bother asking at the first place?

Great afternoon with Rob, the publican, and his team of Reece, Luke, Tommy as well as all the bar staff. Thank you for the BBQ, beers and table tennis (funny as) making today like an old style pub atmosphere. Very enjoyable. From Bill Houlahan

I just popped in for a drink, a very spacious bar, with different outlets. I Imagine nights and weekends must be quite busy. I'm here midweek during office hours when everyone is at work. 😉😎. As usual I am enjoying a margarita. $19.95 a little pricey for me. But damn it's so good, i will have one more before i go...

Just had a great rump steak. Cooked perfectly. The poke bowl with salmon was perfectly done as well and so well presented. Bistro is definitely worth a try.

Robert the Licensee is a gem. He is always available with a smile on his face. He goes above and beyond for people's needs and is always accommodating. He helps his staff when very busy by glass collecting, cleaning, preparing tables, food service, etc which I have never witnessed in any other establishment. He greets people with an endearing manner which makes you want to visit again. Thankyou Robert for making Caringbah Hotel an enjoyable visit

Rob is outstanding. Not only did he show me exactly where my room is, he also told me everything about my room's amenities. He even highlighted the hotel's after hours doors. Truly S tier service

Had a christening booked for 24 people.When at the church on the day received a message asking me to confirm my booking for 20 people.Had pre paid for 24?When food did come out barely enough for 20 people.I spent most of my afternoon carrying back empty glasses.Dirty plates left on tables until function finished.Some food boiling hot some Luke warm.Tried to handle my complaint in house to save embarrassing the pub.? Who cares no one.Never again I should have known better.Next time one of Ferros pubs.They know what they're doing.I thought being my local I might have been looked after?No typical Woolworths.I should add Luke the manager on duty did his best.He did have a whole pub to run.

The rooms upstairs are small. Friendly and helpful staff. Reasonable priced drinks 35 a bottle of champagne

Radiators last night - so disappointing that you can not get the bands to start at 8.30pm
You have other bars in the venue have the NRL on there.
Support band started at 9.15 Radiators at 10.15 played one song the lead went missing for 15 minutes
Waste of time and money attending honestly wake up Caringbah Hotel and get your act into gear!! If it isn't bad enough the venue is small non existent air conditioning you can't even get the bands to start on time!!!!!

What a GREAT place to stay, eat n play.
Staff were friendly and accommodating especially I think her name was Shan. From check in to waiting on tables and behind the bar she was beautiful and amazing how she went about her job. We were in the area for a Pickleball Tournament. We had a group with 5 rooms and would highly recommend the Caringbah Hotel/Night cap Hotel to anyone.

Don't recommend for food and it was terrible! Paid $43 for an eye fillet steak and had to pay an extra $2 for gravy! Veggies are over-boiled and horrible. Margarita pizza had no basil and was thin, bland and full of tomato sauce - spicy beef nachos.. unsure where the spice ran off too, or where the flavour migrated, please let me know when you find it and I'll come and collect.

Stayed overnight and had a really great experience. They were able to accommodate our last minute booking and the staff were very friendly and personable. Happy to help.
Stayed in a room with two double beds and there was plenty of room. Bathroom had everything you needed. Loved the little breakfast boxes in the room, perfect for my daughter.
Had dinner downstairs and the food was great too.

This Hotel is exceptional.
My husband and I usually spent a rare night somewhere in Sydney and I can say we were very impressed with our room and the best service from the day manager who checked us in.
We will Return. Room was much bigger than expected, clean and modern.
Food and drinks very reasonable.
Free drinks voucher, complimentary water and breakfast pack a great addition.
Netflix too !

Dined at The Caringbah Hotel this evening, new chef started today, beautiful satay chicken and Teriyaki Salmon. Great service from a venue that is one the last of the original pubs in the Shire. Wish there was more pubs like this ?

Spent the night here over a weekend, I wish we spent an extra night! The staff were just so amazing! Vivian, the girls behind the bar and the security were just so lovely. We enjoyed our short stay, the rooms were very clean and bistro food was great. Thanks Caringbah team, hope to see you again soon.

Deceptively brilliant. At first glance it looks small, but actually has loads of room, everything worked, comfortable bed, great shower. even milk in the fridge for coffee.

Food dramatically decreased in quality and presentation. Visited on Sunday and waited over one hour for a steak sandwich. This was very upsetting as I had to cancel my afternoon plans just to wait for the food. My time was completely wasted and I paid already so couldn't do anything about it. Was offered an explanation that there was a backlog of orders. Very unfortunate decline of what used to be a pleasant bistro.

Great place to stay. Rooms very clean and tidy. Friendly and helpful staff explaining and showing how to access room and the exits. Nice little breakfast packs included and plenty of toiletries.
I'd stay again for sure.

The tall older blonde lady was extremely rude and abrupt. Was running around the frantically and nearly dropped the drinks on us. Food came out at completely different times and was served cold after 45 minutes of ordering. Dirty venue as well, we were there for about 90 minutes and the table next to us had trash on it the whole time. Younger lady in the blue shirt went out of her way to help though.

Disappointing.
My son's kids' meal came without the ice cream as offered, and after asking for it, I was told to wait. After waiting for 20 minutes, I gave up. I won't come back even if they have the proper Bon Jovi show. ?

I've been there last night. We ordered trough the QR code and the food took long to be served. The cheeseburger kids meal what a disappointment, to serve that better don't have it in the kids menu at all. They didn't send the ice cream that was included in the kids meal and after requested it the waitress told us that would bring it, after wait for 15 minutes we left with no ice cream. The chicken schnitzel had no salt and had some cartilage in it. Really nice room, but service and food disappointing. First time and also the last time.

A big shout out to Caringbah Hotel for their service and food tonight. All the staff went above and beyond to create a great experience for our group of 7. I ate a bocconcini salad which was tasty and a side of the sweet potato fries- yum. All the schnitzels on the table got the tick of approval too. There's a really great wine list too. Thanks so much.

Grace is the best bar tender i have ever had in my life, and skye is a slayer and they both deserve a raise so please give them lost of money as the deserve it because they are the best people in the entire world. I love you grace

Stayed for four nights, kept awake by other guests at night, thin walls, pub open until 3pm down stairs, staff great, rooms clean, no road noise but problems from restaurant exhaust fans going all night. Very high step into bathroom, work, health and safety I think for some as no bar to pull yourself up into bathroom if senior, clean comfortable beds. Kettle doesn't fit under vanity tap to fill up and no green tea in service area
But a good amount of biscuits.

Stayed here for 2 nights and I would not recommend. The check-in process was uncomfortably long and there was no elevator so we had to carry our luggage up 2 flights of stairs. The studio double room was scarily bad. Strong mould smell coming from the bathroom, no smart TV as advertised, only 1 bedside table lamp, harsh fluorescent lights, stained carpets, and suspicious-looking hairs on the toilet seat upon arrival. We were upgraded to the studio twin queen room, which was infinitely better, but both rooms were extremely bright at night due to not having good black-out blinds. Both mornings we were startled awake by the incessant noise made by the cleaning staff very early (around 7am). This included yelling, vacuum cleaning, door slamming, and unidentifiable banging of some kind of metal. The walls are so thin you could probably punch through them. Dodgy area so there were constant sirens up and down the street outside. The hotel has clearly done their best to update the rooms but overall this place is beyond rough.

For $24 my chicken schnitzel wasnt the best iv had & the $2 extra I had to pay for my gravy was not worth it. I got 1 tiny cardboard tub of gravy which equalled to a mouthful. Not worth it.

I was there last night. I drove there after being at the Cronulla Theatre to meet friends who had been there watching the World Cup. I suddenly was escorted out by a big bouncer, telling me urgently I had to leave. Had something happened? Had I been witness to something I wasn't aware of? I was worried and shocked.

When I was then told I'd had too much to drink and they 'could no longer have me in the establishment.' I had had one small wine, at their venue about half an hour prior. My only drink all day.

Moments earlier my friend and I were saying how all our friends go to Cronulla venues and we should get them to come here etc. Honestly I now understand why such a big venue is empty on a Saturday night.

I am still a bit shaken and upset. If you don't want people to drink (a drink) don't sell alcohol, then treat them like they have done something wrong.

I think RSA is necessary to protect all of us but:
- I was not approached in a customer friendly or respectful manner
- I was escorted very publicly and loudly in front of the pub and my friends by a very intimidating bouncer
- I was not given any reason why I was being removed, or what behaviour possibly could have led to this, besides we believe you've been drinking elsewhere - which was absoloutely not true.

I felt discriminated against. Instead of now encouraging friends to visit Caringbah I will be going to Cronulla. Where I have never ever been treated so poorly, in fact I have never experienced this treatment in any venue ever. I'm sure Liam was trying to do his job, but in this instance he got it wrong.

Excellent customer service. I think my waitresses name was Rose.

However there was an odour of urine throughout the venue.

Definitely best steaks in Carringerbah.

Apologies for a lack of photos. Theres nothing inherently wrong with this place. It's another QR code dining experience, so customer service is basically non existent.
The food was kinda slow, but it wasn't bad.. just not impressive either. Wouldve given 2.5 stars if had the option

Constructive criticism........overall disappointing.
1. Booked table for 8 on 03/09/22 (APPROX1PM) in my name (Bruce) for 1815. Booking confirmed by email. Then I received a text confirming booking. Whilst I was at a nearby concert (mobile turned off) I received another text at 4.15pm requesting me to confirm my booking. TOTAL OVERKILL!!!
2. My group arrived at 1815.......table only set for 6; I had 9.........(table no. 10). No one was available for service; I moved another table to join our table. It was very dirty. I had to lean over the bistro counter to fetch a cloth cleaner.
3. When I ordered a chicken schnitzel without dressing on the salad it came out with dressing. I told the guy; he said he was only the delivery guy and the kitchen was busy???
4. I also ordered 2 x rump steaks at the same time as in '3' above, with mushroom sauce, which was an additional charge?? BUT when delivered only one had a very tiny serving of sauce. Same delivery guy; same comment as he had earlier.
I could well have asked to speak to someone in authority but bit my tongue for peace.
The 9 of us spent a lot of money for drinks/meals but overall service was poor. Businesses complain about poor patronages but any wonder with our experience at Caringbah Hotel!!!!!!!
So you sent me an email for feedback on our experience...WELL...YOU GOT IT,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

My son tried to attend this hotel with his father last night after watching the NRL. He was refused entry despite being sober. This is the second time he has been refused entry for "looking intoxicated" at this venue. My son told the security staff that he has a disability and he is being discriminated against by being refused entry when sober. He was told to "call the police if he didn't like it." Give your staff better training Caringbah Hotel. Do better for the marginalised people in your local community.

I attended the venue to see my favourite band this evening. booked a hotel room and had a lovely dinner before the show. During the opening band at 8pm a security guard came up to me and told me I had had too much to drink and had tp leave, but i had only had 2 drinks (and a full dinner!) Very disappointed with the way I was unfairly removed from the venue would not recommend seeing live music here

Went here to see a band and got kicked out after 2 drinks at 8pm because I was "intoxicated". Tried to complain to the venue manager but apparently he "didn't have time to deal with this". We had a room booked and everything so ended up driving home. Horrible security guards. Definitely requesting a full refund and will NEVER come back again.
EDIT: they gave me a refund for the hotel and asked me to change my review! Lol

Had lunch with my sister and daughter, staff amazing, meal perfect. Highly recommend to all.

Me and my partner went here for Valentine's Day as they were doing a set menu. I was very impressed with the quality and variety of the food. I had moreton bay bug and the sizes were very generous. 5 separate courses and 2 glasses of wine for $60. Definitely would recommend

Took my elderly father there for lunch. Food was great. He loved it. One of the staff(kristie I think) was amazing. She was very helpful. Might have to make it my new local. 5 stars

Dined here for Mothers Day lunch. Food was delicious and had a lovely time, staff were friendly. Would recommend!!!

Easy to make a booking via TheFork. Easy to make (multiple) adjustments to the booking. Good selection of meals and beverages. Accommodating and pleasant staff. All contributed to an enjoyable outing.

Dropped back in this weekend and their new menu is a ripper. I had the seafood basket and my misses had the satay chicken and both were bang on! And they were only charging $5 for a Carlton Draught Schooner. So lucky this is our local after moving into the area

Great venue to wind down and have a beer. Be sure to check out the bistro menu and specials. Steak was cooked to perfection. Thanks Cazbah

Food Awesome - Prawn Spring Rolls are to die for. Service is best I have had in a long time and great to see Covid standards are still high.
Will be back :)

Staff are so friendly and the monthly specials make it a good choice. I would say that more security are needed though. I was there on a Monday night after work and there were some customers who were a bit scary/off putting. Other customers had to step in to stop them because they were being so threatening. Security is the only thing I would change

Not too bad.
The bar attendant could have put a friendlier expression on her face - I felt like I owe them money or something.

The food was pretty average tbh, nothing to write home about. I had better steaks for 12 bucks in the city than the rump in this place.
I do not recommend it unfortunately.

The friendliest staff in the world! This pub is welcoming, has three different bars, great food, and some lovely cocktails. Staff care about their patrons and always strive for success. I wouldn't go anywhere else. When the bands come back...it'll be even better!

Been the local go to for a good few years, always a great atmosphere for afternoon drinks and great fun on weekends. Staff are super friendly and they also have the best hot chips around!

Nice place. Always a good spot for a sneaky one after work. Great schnitties too!

Awesome and quality sleep.You wont regret it.Worth every dollar.Air conditioning A1.Amenities A1.Guaranteed best accommodation.Support you local business in the shire.Support Caringbah Hotel.A+++