This place does indeed have the appearance stated in previous reviews. Dark, somewhat subterranean.. the exact opposite of many modern steel, glass and polished-wood venues. And that really appealed to us, it's a bit like an old English pub where you can hear yourself, and others, talk. The food was excellent, on both occasions we went on our week-long Melbourne holiday. The roo on mashed potato and then the daily roast (pork on my day), were flawless.
The waitstaff was friendly and helpful.
Honestly, if I lived here, this would be my local.